Children s Books, Kids Books, Stories for Kids

Starting Preschool Books to Read With Your Kids

[jewellery making Books] DOC The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise ☆ Darío Fernández-Morera – DOC or Kindle eBook


10 thoughts on “The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise

  1. says:

    Fernandez Morera strips away the veil created by politically correct modern historians to look at the real face of Muslim Spain based on contemporary predominantly Arab sources Conscious that he is taking on the entrenched academic establishment Professor Fernadez Morera documents his book meticulously uoting numerous sources for each assertion and providing than 100 pages of notes What emerges is a hideous image of br

  2. says:

    Edited on 12920 to add Here book chapter based on the blog post on 7619 to add On the basis of my blog post about this book I was invited to contribute a chapter to a volume on extreme right historiography which is forthcoming and wh

  3. says:

    A while back I was watching a well known travel show on You Tube about the Andalusian area of Spain Once they started going on and on about wonderful it all supposedly was under Muslim rule I was about ready to pop My blood pressure went up a couple of notches I’m sure I kept mumbling to the screen “Brother please”

  4. says:

    The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise Muslims Christians and Jews Under Islamic Rule in Medieval Spain by Dario Fernandez Mor

  5. says:

    Excellent reading for people with islami phobic tendencies but little of historical value for anyone else The very broad brush taken by the author to paint the Spanish conuest as an Islamic holy war is ridiculous reason when he himself concedes that the very first raids by the Berbers yielded much booty and many beautiful captives w

  6. says:

    The author DESTROYS the myths by John Esposito and other so called Islamic scholars about how wonderful Spain was supposed to have

  7. says:

    This books re examines and re interprets the depiction of the historical territory of Al Andalus – medieval Spain under Islamic rule The author asserts that historical facts have been molded to suit modern political agendas That is he asserts that the unpleasant realities of history have been downplayed in order to advan

  8. says:

    This book is ferociously erudite but tinged with obsession True nearly all modern academic and popular mention of Muslim Spain endorses an easily disproved falsehood—that Muslim Spain was a golden land of tolerance offering uniue scientific and cultural advancement So I suppose that the opposite falsehood that Muslim Spain was a nasty land of unbroken intolerance where nothing was accomplished in a sense merely balanc

  9. says:

    Please give my review a helpful vote Myth of the Andalusian Paradise by Dario Fernandez MoreraThis is a detailed well supported and highly engaging book The thesis of the author Dario Fernandez Morera is that Spain prior to the Muslim conuest was a civilized society that was conuered by barbarians who thereaft

  10. says:

    This is a great book that really has me wondering about what passes as scholarship at many of our institutions of higer le

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


free download á eBook or Kindle ePUB é Darío Fernández-Morera

The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise

C Caliphate’s conuest of Spain Far from a land of religious tolerance Islamic Spain was marked by religious and therefore cultural repression in all areas of life and the marginalization of Christians and other groups all this in the service of social control by autocratic rulers and a class of religious authoriti This book is ferociously erudite but tinged with obsession True nearly all modern academic and popular mention of Muslim Spain endorses an easily disproved falsehood that Muslim Spain was a golden land of tolerance offering uniue scientific and cultural advancement So I suppose that the opposite falsehood that Muslim Spain was a nasty land of unbroken intolerance where nothing was accomplished in a sense merely balances the scales But a reader of The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise still feels like he s once again only getting part of the picture and getting berated into the bargain rather than getting what most readers really want which is an analysis that is objective as possibleIt is no secret that it is difficult today to get a straight story about any aspect of historical Muslim world Most offerings range from laughably false and whitewashed pro Islam anything by Karen Armstrong or many other authors to one note one sided vitriol against Islam anything by Robert Spencer This difficulty exists because Islam today lies at the intersection of numerous political suabbles ranging from the Israeli Palestinian conflict to European ideological multiculturalism to numerous breeds of oppression theory to fears of terrorism and of a resurgent Islam in a clash of civilizations Therefore nearly all publications since 1980 or so have a distinct ideological tinge as do many earlier originating in anti Catholicism such as Runciman s histories of the Crusades It would be nice if for any period in Muslim history authors would simply address the reality of what happened not imposing the template of their politics on either the substance of or the focus upon the actions of the protagonists Thus in medieval Spain rather than talking about whether Abd al Rahman I was tolerant or intolerant we should talk about what he did and why But unfortunately that is not this book Oh we are told what he did but only the parts that show he was intolerant Which is doubtless true but I doubt he was as much a one trick pony as the author tell usDar o Fern ndez Morera painstakingly frames his book in direct opposition to the lumbering philo Muslim herd of recent decades Each chapter and sub chapter is headed by uotations from eminent scholars the purpose of which is to set the substance of those uotations and those scholars up for being demolished in the succeeding pages This is a very effective device for it as the Marxists say heightens the contradictions And Fern ndez Morera does indeed accomplish the demolition he seeks Thus there is never any doubt about his purpose which he achieves with the focus of AhabMore precisely the author s purpose is not just to undermine the myth of a golden age of tolerance it is to focus on the domination of the Maliki school of Islam in Muslim Spain and to claim that in effect Muslim Spain often functioned as a type of hierocracy where Maliki clerics held substantial political power The traditional view of most Muslim systems is not that they were theocratic or hierocratic for that matter but that they were caesaropapist that secular rulers had very significant religious power Maliki clerics in Spain were not interested in tolerance or anything at all resembling what modern Western liberals want That is the secular rulers of Muslim Spain may or may not at any given time have been doctrinally flexible in their personal lives drowning themselves in wine and concubines though the latter is generally accepted in Islam but the actual conduct of broader society was dictated by the legal thought and practice of inflexible and intolerant Maliki clericsFern ndez Morera begins with various framing and definitional matters If one concept characterizes the book it s that convivencia the propagandistic term often used to conclude with little evidence that there was a wonderful spirit of mutual tolerance throughout Muslim Spain is wholly bogus As the author points out that there were mutual influences among different groups in Muslim Spain shows nothing mutual influences always exist under every conueror Thus This book s interpretive stance is Machiavellian not Panglossian Even when individual Muslims Jews and Christians cooperated with one another out of convenience necessity mutual sympathy or love these three groups and their numerous subgroups engaged for centuries in struggles for power and cultural survival manifested in often subtle ways that should not be glossed over for the sake of modern ideals of tolerance diversity and convivencia And again just because certain secular rulers lived dissolute lives does not mean that was the norm for regular people any than I might add that just because Charles II had lots of mistresses polygamy was the norm in Restoration England If the author had limited himself to proving this thesis rather than stamping on the idea that there was ever any element of convivencia in Muslim Spain his book would have been very successfulRather than relying on secondary sources Fern ndez Morera uses mostly primary sources This is because of the corruption of the secondary sources largely because of the Gulf states their funding of Western university departments related to Islam is vast but conditioned on toeing the pro Sunni Muslim line something academics under the spell of Edward Said and oppression studies have no problem with The author s grasp of languages seems to be immense which certainly helps him offer a lot of backup to his thesis There are a hundred pages of footnotes most to primary sources The reader can t therefore complain that the book contains falsehoods unlike say every paragraph Karen Armstrong writes But he can complain of imbalanceThe author begins with Conuest and Reconuest in which Fern ndez Morera attacks the modern attempt to recast the Islamic conuest of Visigothic Spain as a mere migration having no religious component or jihad element This modern argument is obviously on weak ground since that would make the Muslim incursion into Christian Spain uniue in Muslim history and contrary to Muslim theology Not that Fern ndez Morera attempts to parse Muslim theology which has many strands over many centuries His point is simpler the actual conuerors of Spain told us exactly why they did it over and over and whether there is actually such a thing as jihad as inner struggle in Islam no conueror of Spain ever mentioned jihad in any context other than the physical conuest and domination of the Christians and JewsThe conuest of Christian Spain was fast accomplished through both war and short term uickly broken treaties though its speed was not without historical parallel roughly ten years And the author notes something else not often mentioned today the Arab conuerors as well as the defeated Christians again and again pointed out the critical role of the Jews in supporting the Arab conuest including through administration of conuered cities as the Arabs moved on to new conuests This is hardly surprising Muslim conuests throughout the Middle East were greatly helped not just by the weakness and disorganization of conuered societies such as Sassanid Persia and Visigothic Spain itself but also by the freuent active cooperation of religious minorities such as the Nestorian Christians in Egypt who especially in the early years of the Muslim conuests saw Islam as just another Christian heresy and one that would reduce taxes and let them practice their brand of Christianity in peace thus one whose rule was preferable to the Greek Roman EmpireIt s in this first chapter that some of the book s defects as writing show up All too freuently the book reads like a flat recitation of facts and references delivered in staccato fashion with not infreuent repetition of the same facts We are told repeatedly about tabiun contemporaries of Muhammad s companions whose presence on campaign was regarded as highly desirable that Ibn Khaldun disparaged Arab building techniues and most often of all that the famous Mosue of C rdoba now thankfully a cathedral was built on the Basilica of St Vincent destroyed by the conuerors All these things are interesting and even relevant but being told once would have been enough and the repetition either indicates bad editing or the edge of obsession probably the latter since most of these are used in service of a negative light being cast on the conuerors No doubt much they did was negative but they must have done some neutral or even good things What those are we are not toldIn the next chapter the author s main purpose is to establish that Visigothic Spain far from being a backward society improved by superior Muslim culture was in fact a flowering hybrid of Roman and Visigothic culture largely destroyed by a mostly retrograde Islam except for a few elements that survived such as the Visigothic horseshoe arch often described as an Islamic element This is a variation on the generally accepted modern view that the Dark Ages weren t that dark at all I have a lot of sympathy for this view and elements of it are surely true including that it was not Arabs rather it was mostly the Greek Roman Empire that preserved the texts of Aristotle and other Classical writers supplemented by Christian scribes under Islam On the other hand both documentary and archaeological evidence of this period is slim and the author I think tries to spin too much out of too little But what I have no sympathy for is his freuent references to and reliance on a secondary source Emmet Scott s Mohammed and Charlemagne Revisited This is a 2012 book updating the thesis of Henri Pirenne from the 1930s that the Dark Ages were caused by the rise of Islam because it ended trade and most contacts between Europe and the East both in the Mediterranean and to a lesser extent overland thus turning Europe temporarily into a backwater when it was otherwise still flourishing after the fall of Rome This thesis certainly has something to it although it tends to get little modern hearing since it suggests that there could be something negative about the impact of Islam But Scott s present day book which endorses and updates Pirenne comes very close to endorsing the bizarre Phantom Time Hypothesis that today is really 1720 not 2017 because Emperor Otto III and Pope Sylvester II inserted the years AD 614 911 into the calendar The supposed proof of this turns on a nearly complete lack of archaeological evidence for those centuries which might support Pirenne but given say Chinese records the idea of phantom time is sheer stupidity like most conspiracy theories positing multi generational gnosis I read Scott s book when it came out in 2012 and this was a disturbing element of the book Though Scott never directly endorsed the Phantom Time Hypothesis instead tiptoeing around it he was clearly sympathetic Looking around now I see that Scott later in 2014 wrote a book formally endorsing it Therefore that Fern ndez Morera cites Scott heavily does not or should not help his case yes Pirenne may well be right but crackpots should be avoided and the case for the flowering of Visigothic Spain being cut short not overstatedThe rest of the book is taken up with an encyclopedic rendering in multiple chapters of the bad behavior of Muslims toward Jews Christians and women in Muslim Spain Although no informed person really thinks that Muslim Spain was for the 500 years of its existence 700 if you include the 200 years in which it was reduced to the rump of Granada a model of tolerance traditionally the earlier Umayyad dynasty and the fragmented taifa kingdoms which followed it have been regarded as tolerant than the later Almohad and Almoravid dynasties Fern ndez Morera will have none of this relying largely on Maliki texts and primary texts showing the actual application of the rigid Maliki rules he insists that non Muslims were uniformly treated poorly Yes occasional Christians and Jews rose in the Muslim power hierarchy and yes for some periods the rules reuiring constant humiliation of non Muslims weren t aggressively enforced But mostly they were interspersed with pogroms and massacres of both Christians and Jews the latter in particular came in for abuse because of their education and prosperity some things apparently never change Women always had vastly freedom and power in Europe than anywhere in Islam including Muslim Spain And dhimmi status was the best Christians could hope for when they weren t being accused of being polytheists because of belief in the Trinity and killed outright which was only protection in the sense of protection racket an organized form of monetary extortion in exchange for a temporary abeyance of violence against the personNone of this is surprising to any educated person the uniform history of Islam in power is that of a triumphalist religion in which some and some only minority religions are allowed to exist as long as they pay taxes and recognize the temporal authority of Islam over them I have no doubt that all the data texts and examples Fern ndez Morera offers are both true and accurate All this is a valuable corrective to the philo Muslim anti Christian view that normally dominates in the academy and in the media today supplemented by outright lies often offered by American politicians as they declare their willing submission to Islam But this book offers only a one dimensional picture no different than the one dimensional picture usually offered of Christian Europe as a nasty intolerant place Sometimes it was sometimes it wasn t and the same has to be true of Muslim Spain Any ambiguity in this book is always resolved against Islam The reader or at least this reader is unhappy not to get a complete picture Maybe the corrective is needed but the reader is tired of being a kickball in the ideological wars Yes the Reconuista was awesome and should be celebrated and isn t celebrated enough today But that doesn t mean we should endorse viewing history through a pinhole

read & download The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise

Scholars journalists and even politicians uphold Muslim ruled medieval Spain “al Andalus” as a multicultural paradise a place where Muslims Christians and Jews lived in harmonyThere is only one problem with this widely accepted account it is a mythIn this book Northwestern University scholar Darío Fernández Mo A while back I was watching a well known travel show on You Tube about the Andalusian area of Spain Once they started going on and on about wonderful it all supposedly was under Muslim rule I was about ready to pop My blood pressure went up a couple of notches I m sure I kept mumbling to the screen Brother please I m tired so tired of hearing the same old narrative about that period of time the supposed multiculturalist paradise the so called Golden Age I m just not buying into all that political correctness As a Persian I know what they did back in my old country I recently read The Force of Reason by Oriana Fallaci While reading that I became interested in reading this one Oriana addresses the truth about history in Europe during the time of the Muslim invasion and the Crusaders She says it like it is as opposed to some romantic version of a time when everyone supposedly lived in a time of tolerance harmony and peaceful coexistence Whoever believes in the myth of peaceful coexistence that marked the relationships between the conuered and the conuerors should reread the stories of the burned convents and monasteries of the profaned churches of the raped nuns of the Christian or Jewish women abducted to be locked away in their harems He should ponder on the crucifixions of Cordoba the hangings of Granada the beheadings of Toledo and Barcelona of Seville and Zamora The beheadings of Seville ordered by Mutamid the king who used those severed heads heads of Jews and Christians to adorn his palace Invoking the name of Jesus meant instant execution Crucifixion of course or decapitation or hanging or impalement Ringing a bell the same Wearing green the colour of Islam also And when a Muslim passed by every Jew and Christian was obliged to step aside To bow And mind to the Jew or the Christian who dared react to the insults of a Muslim As for the much flaunted detail that the infidel dogs were not obliged to convert to Islam not even encouraged to do so do you know why they were not Because those who converted to Islam did not pay taxes Those who refused on the contrary did This book does a fabulous job of setting the record straight on all the propaganda The amount of research and evidence is amazing I only wish that it had been written in a engaging style and definitely with less repetition This book is not an easy read but I don t think it was meant to be either It was written by an academic and is uite scholarly Some of my favorite uotes Professional self preservation as well as political correctness and economics has affected academic research in certain fields of study in contrast to the fearlessness demonstrated by professors when unmasking horrors in such dangerous areas of investigation as Christian Europe the burning of witches colonialism and Catholic Spain the ubiuitous Spanish Inuisition Islamic Spain is no exception to the rule University presses do not want to get in trouble presenting an Islamic domination of even centuries ago as anything but a positive event and academic specialists would rather not portray negatively a subject that constitutes their bread and butter In addition fear of the accusation of Islamophobia has paralyzed many academic researchers Those who portray Islamic Spain as an example of peaceful coexistence freuently cite the fact that Muslim Jewish and Christian groups in al Andalus sometimes lived near one another Even when that was the case however such groups dwelled often than not in their own neighborhoods More to the point even when individual Muslims Jews and Christians cooperated with one another out of convenience necessity mutual sympathy or love these three groups and their own numerous subgroups engaged for centuries in struggles for power and cultural survival manifested in often subtle ways that should not be glossed over for the sake of modern ideals of tolerance diversity and convivencia It is significant that Muslim leaders punished their own if they suspected a lack of Islamic zeal Muslim warriors could be punished with death for apostasy which contributed to the fervor of the invaders According to al utiyya when Musa Ibn Nusayr s son was named governor he married the wife of King Rodrigo and began adopting Christian ways and military leaders cut his head off in the mihrab of a mosue and sent his head to the caliph Tunnel Through Time ruled medieval Spain “al Andalus” as a multicultural paradise a place where Muslims Christians and Jews lived in harmonyThere is only one problem with this widely accepted account it is a mythIn this book Northwestern University scholar Darío Fernández Mo A while back I was watching a well known travel show on You Tube about the Andalusian area of Spain Once they started going on and on about wonderful it all supposedly was under Muslim Game of Bimbofication, Part 3 rule I was about Game of Bimbofication, Part 2 ready to pop My blood pressure went up a couple of notches I m sure I kept mumbling to the screen Brother please I m tired so tired of hearing the same old narrative about that period of time the supposed multiculturalist paradise the so called Golden Age I m just not buying into all that political correctness As a Persian I know what they did back in my old country I Sermons Preached Upon Several Occasions, Vol. 1 of 5 recently The Fatima Century read The Force of Reason by Oriana Fallaci While Leah Starrs Revenge reading that I became interested in Pieces 8 (Pieces, reading this one Oriana addresses the truth about history in Europe during the time of the Muslim invasion and the Crusaders She says it like it is as opposed to some Time Flies and Other Short Plays romantic version of a time when everyone supposedly lived in a time of tolerance harmony and peaceful coexistence Whoever believes in the myth of peaceful coexistence that marked the Fall (VIP Book 3) (English Edition) relationships between the conuered and the conuerors should Drawing Dead (Faolan OConnor Book 1) reread the stories of the burned convents and monasteries of the profaned churches of the Trails & Tales of Yosemite & the Central Sierra raped nuns of the Christian or Jewish women abducted to be locked away in their harems He should ponder on the crucifixions of Cordoba the hangings of Granada the beheadings of Toledo and Barcelona of Seville and Zamora The beheadings of Seville ordered by Mutamid the king who used those severed heads heads of Jews and Christians to adorn his palace Invoking the name of Jesus meant instant execution Crucifixion of course or decapitation or hanging or impalement Ringing a bell the same Wearing green the colour of Islam also And when a Muslim passed by every Jew and Christian was obliged to step aside To bow And mind to the Jew or the Christian who dared Chinas Son react to the insults of a Muslim As for the much flaunted detail that the infidel dogs were not obliged to convert to Islam not even encouraged to do so do you know why they were not Because those who converted to Islam did not pay taxes Those who Welcome to the Desert of the Real refused on the contrary did This book does a fabulous job of setting the Dead End Bluff record straight on all the propaganda The amount of King Noah Blindness and the Vision of Seers research and evidence is amazing I only wish that it had been written in a engaging style and definitely with less Princess to Pleasure Slave Chronicles (Book Three): Lusty Prey of the Huntress (English Edition) repetition This book is not an easy Factory of Death read but I don t think it was meant to be either It was written by an academic and is uite scholarly Some of my favorite uotes Professional self preservation as well as political correctness and economics has affected academic Thirteen Plus One (The Winnie Years, research in certain fields of study in contrast to the fearlessness demonstrated by professors when unmasking horrors in such dangerous areas of investigation as Christian Europe the burning of witches colonialism and Catholic Spain the ubiuitous Spanish Inuisition Islamic Spain is no exception to the Rapid Math Without A Calculator rule University presses do not want to get in trouble presenting an Islamic domination of even centuries ago as anything but a positive event and academic specialists would Almost Late for School rather not portray negatively a subject that constitutes their bread and butter In addition fear of the accusation of Islamophobia has paralyzed many academic Seduced by My Doms (The Doms of Genesis, researchers Those who portray Islamic Spain as an example of peaceful coexistence freuently cite the fact that Muslim Jewish and Christian groups in al Andalus sometimes lived near one another Even when that was the case however such groups dwelled often than not in their own neighborhoods More to the point even when individual Muslims Jews and Christians cooperated with one another out of convenience necessity mutual sympathy or love these three groups and their own numerous subgroups engaged for centuries in struggles for power and cultural survival manifested in often subtle ways that should not be glossed over for the sake of modern ideals of tolerance diversity and convivencia It is significant that Muslim leaders punished their own if they suspected a lack of Islamic zeal Muslim warriors could be punished with death for apostasy which contributed to the fervor of the invaders According to al utiyya when Musa Ibn Nusayr s son was named governor he married the wife of King Rodrigo and began adopting Christian ways and military leaders cut his head off in the mihrab of a mosue and sent his head to the caliph

free download á eBook or Kindle ePUB é Darío Fernández-Morera

Rera tells the full story of Islamic Spain The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise shines light on hidden history by drawing on an abundance of primary sources that scholars have ignored as well as archaeological evidence only recently unearthedThis supposed beacon of peaceful coexistence began of course with the Islami The author DESTROYS the myths by John Esposito and other so called Islamic scholars about how wonderful Spain was supposed to have been under Islamic ruleThis book has so many footnotes that you finish reading the epilogue at 49% through the Kindle versionIf you are tired of the kowtowing to Islam by professors whose jobs are endowed by Saudi Arabia then you should read this book which will give you plenty of ammunition and come backs to their LIES The 7 Components of Transformative Organizing Theory recently unearthedThis supposed beacon of peaceful coexistence began of course with the Islami The author DESTROYS the myths by John Esposito and other so called Islamic scholars about how wonderful Spain was supposed to have been under Islamic The Big Golden Book of Poetry ruleThis book has so many footnotes that you finish NITRO: The Incredible Rise and Inevitable Collapse of Ted Turner's WCW reading the epilogue at 49% through the Kindle versionIf you are tired of the kowtowing to Islam by professors whose jobs are endowed by Saudi Arabia then you should Wild Man Creek (Virgin River, read this book which will give you plenty of ammunition and come backs to their LIES

  • Hardcover
  • 376
  • The Myth of the Andalusian Paradise
  • Darío Fernández-Morera
  • English
  • 06 August 2018
  • 9781610170956

© 2021 Children s Books, Kids Books, Stories for Kids

Tessa Young is an 18 year old college student with a simple life, excellent grades, and a sweet boyfriend She always has things planned out ahead of time, until she meets a rude boy named Harry, with too many tattoos and piercings who shatters her plans.